Carlisle promoted to League one after 5-4 penalties win after 1-1 full time finish. Well done to them and look forward to another away trip to Stockport next season

Well done to them but would have been nice to lose Stockport and their budget. Saves a lot of people a lot of fuel money losing Carlisle mind.

Quoted from LH

Well done to them but would have been nice to lose Stockport and their budget. Saves a lot of people a lot of fuel money losing Carlisle mind.

I think they'll only add 3/4 to what they've already got, had a very good squad already and if they didn't start slow as per usual then probably would have gone up automatically.

How many teams with daft budgets next season in league 2?
Stockport
Wrexham
Salford
Notts
Gillingham
Donny seem to be going for it
Bradford
Mansfield
Maybe more
We just need to take inspiration from Carlisle & Stevenage -
budget very rarely = success in league 2

Teams like Salford, Mansfield and Bradford have been operating with big budgets for a while, doesn’t necessarily result in more points.

Id also imagine agents and players are wise to who has money, in reality they probably end up over paying for decent/average players.

Quoted from Mappers

How many teams with daft budgets next season in league 2?
Stockport
Wrexham
Salford
Notts
Gillingham
Donny seem to be going for it
Bradford
Mansfield
Maybe more
We just need to take inspiration from Carlisle & Stevenage -
budget very rarely = success in league 2

In terms of financial competition, both the National League and League Two play-offs haven’t really gone our way, with the wealthiest, or at least “spendiest”, clubs coming up (Notts County) and staying down (Stockport, Salford and Bradford) respectively.

Still, that doesn’t overly concern me; as others have pointed out correlations between budget and promotions are sporadic at best at this level. That, and there’s something oddly comforting about having Town, Stockport, Wrexham and Notts County in the same league together again. Games against those sides provided some of tue very best memories of our 21/22 promotion season. Here’s to the same again!

Surely village green will spend?

We have a good record over  the last couple of season's against Stockport.

We lost both games to Carlisle this season so right result for us I am thinking.

More Mariners going to Stockport and more of them coming here so good all round.

Glad to see Carlisle go up. An unfashionable team out on a limb.

Sounds familiar.

Quoted from ginnywings

Glad to see Carlisle go up. An unfashionable team out on a limb.

Sounds familiar.

Indeed glad i never was fashion conscious...UTM 2023--24.

Quoted from Poojah

In terms of financial competition, both the National League and League Two play-offs haven’t really gone our way, with the wealthiest, or at least “spendiest”, clubs coming up (Notts County) and staying down (Stockport, Salford and Bradford) respectively.

Still, that doesn’t overly concern me; as others have pointed out correlations between budget and promotions are sporadic at best at this level. That, and there’s something oddly comforting about having Town, Stockport, Wrexham and Notts County in the same league together again. Games against those sides provided some of tue very best memories of our 21/22 promotion season. Here’s to the same again!

Promotions haven't gone to the biggest budget teams, but by and large they compete at the top end regularly. There's a huge amount of teams going for it next season. It'll take a monumental effort to compete with them if we don't open the purse strings. We're clearly a long way off that right now

34000 for the final yesterday, less than the national league game

Quoted from pen penfras

Promotions haven't gone to the biggest budget teams, but by and large they compete at the top end regularly. There's a huge amount of teams going for it next season. It'll take a monumental effort to compete with them if we don't open the purse strings. We're clearly a long way off that right now

Long way off?

We weren't that far away last season considering the rushed pre season we had.

It's not all about budgets.

Quoted from ginnywings

Long way off?

We weren't that far away last season considering the rushed pre season we had.

It's not all about budgets.

On average points per game, we wouldn't have finished above Salford if we'd played an extra 10 games to them. I'd say that's a long way off.

You're right that pre season was short, but that might be why we started off well considering our players hadn't lost the fitness over the summer.

I'm not saying money is everything, but you're not going to punch above your financial weight for long. How many teams with smaller budgets punch above their weight for more than 5 years?

In the Conference, we were the strong team, iutrunning and out passing the opponents.

This season, I thought that Swindon set a Div 2 tone  as we were woeful and totally outplayed.

That, for me, showed how much our passing, and ball dwelling needs to be imoroved. The cup run was all about teams above us allowing Town players space and time, which we made good use of, but other teams who harass and hurry us show up the frailities big style !

Quoted from pen penfras

Promotions haven't gone to the biggest budget teams, but by and large they compete at the top end regularly. There's a huge amount of teams going for it next season. It'll take a monumental effort to compete with them if we don't open the purse strings. We're clearly a long way off that right now

I think it depends what you mean by "opening the purse strings". It's on record that the budget will be bigger than last season, and on the back of higher than forecast gates and an unexpected quarter final cup run I'd expect it to be more than just an incremental step.

But it's unlikely our biggest real terms budget in the best part of two decades will trouble the top 10. At a guess, Bradford, Forest Green, Gillingham, Mansfield, MK Dons, Notts County, Salford, Stockport, and Wrexham will all have deeper pockets than us, and potentially a couple of other wildcards, too. An organic Town budget probably has us somewhere around mid-table, largely due to a series of inorganic budgets elsewhere. That's no fault of anyone at GTFC, rather a mere reflection of the perfect storm of a division we happen to find ourselves in. The richest fourth division of all-time, without a shadow of a doubt.

So what then, should we just write off next season and wait until a few of the sugar-daddied clubs have fúcked off? I don't think so. Stevenage were joint 2nd favourites to be relegated last season, and went on to finish 2nd and go up automatically. Meanwhile none of the top 5 favourites won promotion at all. Carlisle's odds of promotion were longer than our own going into the season. Finance is a big driver of those odds, but ultimately had relatively had little accord with the bottom-line outcomes of the season.

I'm a big believer that our finish of 11th last season is a much bigger achievement than is immediately obvious. It came on the back of a seemingly impossible play-off victory and an impossibly short summer in which we had to regroup, recruit and recondition, ready for the rigours of a significant step-up in level.

The conditions a year on are considerably better. We've had months rather than weeks to prepare for the season ahead, and we are far better equipped with a bona fide recruitment specialist on the payroll, a gold standard data platform at our disposal and a smattering of improved facilities. Oh, and a bigger budget. Let's just explore that a bit deeper for a second.

What does this improved budget look like? I can only speculate, but with circa £1m earned via our cup run and higher than anticipated gates, I would expect it to be somewhere between 20% and 30% north of where we were this season. I don't expect that is going to fundamentally change who we target, but it does make a material difference to our chances of landing them.

For context, that kind of figure means that a top target whom we may have been able to offer £150k to last season means we can now stretch as high as between £180k and £200k - that's a very meaningful difference in a prospective signing's compensation package (about £1,750 a month, after tax). If we work on the assumption that we've not been a million miles away from some targets in the past year, then a 25% increase in offer probably increases our chances of completing a signing by more than 50%. It's a game changing difference.

It is my steadfast belief that the compound effect of our respective advantages over circumstances 12 months ago will see a seismic step forward in our capabilities on the pitch next season. I look to Hurst's second season at Shrewsbury as a barometer of what can be expected. The Shrews finished 3rd, ahead of a host of clubs with significantly larger budgets - including the likes of Charlton, Portsmouth, oh, and Scunthorpe. Remember them? They spent about £6.5m on wages that season, the mentalists.

There is no doubt that League Two is going to be markedly stronger financially this season than it was last, though we should acknowledge we are also a part of that story. Regardless, I expect our own progress to outstrip that of the division as a whole. Does that mean we will go up? Not necessarily. We have a Grand National of a league on our hands next season, but I believe we are absolutely worth an each way bet.

We will be right up there, amongst the Stockport's, Bradford's and the Wrexham's. That is not my hope, that is my expectation.

Quoted from Poojah

I think it depends what you mean by "opening the purse strings". It's on record that the budget will be bigger than last season, and on the back of higher than forecast gates and an unexpected quarter final cup run I'd expect it to be more than just an incremental step.

But it's unlikely our biggest real terms budget in the best part of two decades will trouble the top 10. At a guess, Bradford, Forest Green, Gillingham, Mansfield, MK Dons, Notts County, Salford, Stockport, and Wrexham will all have deeper pockets than us, and potentially a couple of other wildcards, too. An organic Town budget probably has us somewhere around mid-table, largely due to a series of inorganic budgets elsewhere. That's no fault of anyone at GTFC, rather a mere reflection of the perfect storm of a division we happen to find ourselves in. The richest fourth division of all-time, without a shadow of a doubt.

So what then, should we just write off next season and wait until a few of the sugar-daddied clubs have fúcked off? I don't think so. Stevenage were joint 2nd favourites to be relegated last season, and went on to finish 2nd and go up automatically. Meanwhile none of the top 5 favourites won promotion at all. Carlisle's odds of promotion were longer than our own going into the season. Finance is a big driver of those odds, but ultimately had relatively had little accord with the bottom-line outcomes of the season.

I'm a big believer that our finish of 11th last season is a much bigger achievement than is immediately obvious. It came on the back of a seemingly impossible play-off victory and an impossibly short summer in which we had to regroup, recruit and recondition, ready for the rigours of a significant step-up in level.

The conditions a year on are considerably better. We've had months rather than weeks to prepare for the season ahead, and we are far better equipped with a bona fide recruitment specialist on the payroll, a gold standard data platform at our disposal and a smattering of improved facilities. Oh, and a bigger budget. Let's just explore that a bit deeper for a second.

What does this improved budget look like? I can only speculate, but with circa £1m earned via our cup run and higher than anticipated gates, I would expect it to be somewhere between 20% and 30% north of where we were this season. I don't expect that is going to fundamentally change who we target, but it does make a material difference to our chances of landing them.

For context, that kind of figure means that a top target whom we may have been able to offer £150k to last season means we can now stretch as high as between £180k and £200k - that's a very meaningful difference in a prospective signing's compensation package (about £1,750 a month, after tax). If we work on the assumption that we've not been a million miles away from some targets in the past year, then a 25% increase in offer probably increases our chances of completing a signing by more than 50%. It's a game changing difference.

It is my steadfast belief that the compound effect of our respective advantages over circumstances 12 months ago will see a seismic step forward in our capabilities on the pitch next season. I look to Hurst's second season at Shrewsbury as a barometer of what can be expected. The Shrews finished 3rd, ahead of a host of clubs with significantly larger budgets - including the likes of Charlton, Portsmouth, oh, and Scunthorpe. Remember them? They spent about £6.5m on wages that season, the mentalists.

There is no doubt that League Two is going to be markedly stronger financially this season than it was last, though we should acknowledge we are also a part of that story. Regardless, I expect our own progress to outstrip that of the division as a whole. Does that mean we will go up? Not necessarily. We have a Grand National of a league on our hands next season, but I believe we are absolutely worth an each way bet.

We will be right up there, amongst the Stockports, Bradford's and the Wrexham's. That is not my hope, that is my expectation.

I think we have a chance just based on the recent past and history of league 2 .I think you probably have the budget
about right .

Your paragraph about writing off next season is something I have thought about -when, at some point over probably the next 3 seasons league 2 will 'empty out' of the more well financed clubs , the strength of National league teams promoted is going to diminish and it will be a more realistic league to get out of .

Does that mean we don't have a chance of promotion next season? Of course not .
Does it mean a mid table finish would be a bad season ?
Not for me , aslong as we see a continuing plan and better home performances I would take it , if offered now - maybe that's a lack of ambition ; but I feel we are on the right track and it is a matter of time of when but not if  we get to league 1 .
I am patient .
League 1 is a firestorm of a league now , and having the whole club in order will be vital to compete , a little bit longer getting there may not be a bad thing .

That's just my opinion , I know some will expect that million pound striker and the title !

I'm not saying money is everything, but you're not going to punch above your financial weight for long. How many teams with smaller budgets punch above their weight for more than 5 years?[/quote]


That is a very valid point. Money doesn’t necessarily get you promoted but it certainly helps you to keep progressing. We punched above our weight in what is now the Championship for quite a few years, but without a Championship budget our dropping down through the leagues was horribly spectacular. At least with Jason and Andrew at the helm we are now being run properly, but unless we get a sugar daddy with serious big money in the future we’ll always be a small club compared with say Wrexham. In the end money talks. Having said all of that I’d rather support us than be a Man City supporter who only win every week because they have the most money and can therefore buy the best players in the world. Our club has got heart and is now at the centre of the community and engages with the town, Man City is just a money making business. #UTM

Money isn't the be-all and end-all, although it helps. Apart from incoming players in the correct positions we also need those with an excellent mental attitude whose heads don't go down when the opposition score.

Proof of the pudding was the team spirit created in our promotion year. We didn't have the budget of Wrexham, and others, but we got promoted. I think Hurst will spend his money wisely to get another galvanised squad together. Out of those 9 mentioned by Poojah some will still be in League 2 at the end of next season, so money is not going to bring success to all of them.

A lot of attention being shown to our budget, and not enough to Paul Hurst's lucky boxer shorts.

Fortuitous underwear = success, surely?

Some of these clubs are going to be heavily restricted in the coming seasons if they don't find there way out of the league due to the changing of spending rules.

Quoted from LocalLadGTFC

Some of these clubs are going to be heavily restricted in the coming seasons if they don't find there way out of the league due to the changing of spending rules.

There will be a way round any spend rules!

Quoted from acko338

In the Conference, we were the strong team, iutrunning and out passing the opponents.

This season, I thought that Swindon set a Div 2 tone  as we were woeful and totally outplayed.

That, for me, showed how much our passing, and ball dwelling needs to be imoroved. The cup run was all about teams above us allowing Town players space and time, which we made good use of, but other teams who harass and hurry us show up the frailities big style !

Nobody really mentions Swindon. I can see them being very near the top next season..

Quoted from Poojah

I think it depends what you mean by "opening the purse strings". It's on record that the budget will be bigger than last season, and on the back of higher than forecast gates and an unexpected quarter final cup run I'd expect it to be more than just an incremental step.

But it's unlikely our biggest real terms budget in the best part of two decades will trouble the top 10. At a guess, Bradford, Forest Green, Gillingham, Mansfield, MK Dons, Notts County, Salford, Stockport, and Wrexham will all have deeper pockets than us, and potentially a couple of other wildcards, too. An organic Town budget probably has us somewhere around mid-table, largely due to a series of inorganic budgets elsewhere. That's no fault of anyone at GTFC, rather a mere reflection of the perfect storm of a division we happen to find ourselves in. The richest fourth division of all-time, without a shadow of a doubt.

So what then, should we just write off next season and wait until a few of the sugar-daddied clubs have fúcked off? I don't think so. Stevenage were joint 2nd favourites to be relegated last season, and went on to finish 2nd and go up automatically. Meanwhile none of the top 5 favourites won promotion at all. Carlisle's odds of promotion were longer than our own going into the season. Finance is a big driver of those odds, but ultimately had relatively had little accord with the bottom-line outcomes of the season.

I'm a big believer that our finish of 11th last season is a much bigger achievement than is immediately obvious. It came on the back of a seemingly impossible play-off victory and an impossibly short summer in which we had to regroup, recruit and recondition, ready for the rigours of a significant step-up in level.

The conditions a year on are considerably better. We've had months rather than weeks to prepare for the season ahead, and we are far better equipped with a bona fide recruitment specialist on the payroll, a gold standard data platform at our disposal and a smattering of improved facilities. Oh, and a bigger budget. Let's just explore that a bit deeper for a second.

What does this improved budget look like? I can only speculate, but with circa £1m earned via our cup run and higher than anticipated gates, I would expect it to be somewhere between 20% and 30% north of where we were this season. I don't expect that is going to fundamentally change who we target, but it does make a material difference to our chances of landing them.

For context, that kind of figure means that a top target whom we may have been able to offer £150k to last season means we can now stretch as high as between £180k and £200k - that's a very meaningful difference in a prospective signing's compensation package (about £1,750 a month, after tax). If we work on the assumption that we've not been a million miles away from some targets in the past year, then a 25% increase in offer probably increases our chances of completing a signing by more than 50%. It's a game changing difference.

It is my steadfast belief that the compound effect of our respective advantages over circumstances 12 months ago will see a seismic step forward in our capabilities on the pitch next season. I look to Hurst's second season at Shrewsbury as a barometer of what can be expected. The Shrews finished 3rd, ahead of a host of clubs with significantly larger budgets - including the likes of Charlton, Portsmouth, oh, and Scunthorpe. Remember them? They spent about £6.5m on wages that season, the mentalists.

There is no doubt that League Two is going to be markedly stronger financially this season than it was last, though we should acknowledge we are also a part of that story. Regardless, I expect our own progress to outstrip that of the division as a whole. Does that mean we will go up? Not necessarily. We have a Grand National of a league on our hands next season, but I believe we are absolutely worth an each way bet.

We will be right up there, amongst the Stockport's, Bradford's and the Wrexham's. That is not my hope, that is my expectation.

Thinking Wrexham, Stockport, Bradford, Swindon, Doncaster, Mansfield, County, Gillingham, Salford, MK, Walsall and us will be around the top ten. Great league to be involved in next season..

I don't think Swindon will be top end , I talk to one of their fans quite a bit at work and they have their own problems there .

By his account their 2 best performances all season were the two against us and they were in his words 'dreadful' for most of the second half of the season .

It just sums up the inconsistency of League 2 teams , look at Rochdale-they looked good to me in that early season game ,see how that turned out for them .

I fancy Barrow and Doncaster to do well but that's just based on their managers really .

Notts County could find it difficult if they continue with that wide open style (as lovely as it is on the eye as a neutral) as league 2 teams will pick them off on the counter much better than NL teams ,Chesterfield should really have killed them off in that final ; I would fancy us against them tbh .

Quoted from DB

Money isn't the be-all and end-all, although it helps. Apart from incoming players in the correct positions we also need those with an excellent mental attitude whose heads don't go down when the opposition score.

Proof of the pudding was the team spirit created in our promotion year. We didn't have the budget of Wrexham, and others, but we got promoted. I think Hurst will spend his money wisely to get another galvanised squad together. Out of those 9 mentioned by Poojah some will still be in League 2 at the end of next season, so money is not going to bring success to all of them.

If you look at it statistically over the last 5 years probably 1 of the 'favourites' go up at a push 2 in League 2 .
The anomaly which you have never had before is 2 teams coming up with 111 & 107  points - does that make them significantly better than Stockport ? who came 5th with 79 points in league 2 , but obtained 94 points in the NL with 2 fewer games because of Dover if i remember correctly.

I'm not sure ,below Wrexham & Notts the NL was probably quite a lot weaker - us and Stockport gone with Southend in a mess and oldham similiar up until their takeover - Solihull struggled after the Play off final and with a number of basket case clubs at the bottom their for easy pickings it probably inflated their tally even more .

I feel like the NL is going to start to look very much 'non league ' again over the next couple of years.Maybe coverage will diminish now their darlings have departed .

Maybe it was posted elsewhere, maybe not?

Players released: Lewis Bell, Jamie Devitt, Brennan Dickenson, Josh Dixon, Sam Fishburn, Mick Kelly, Joel Senior, Tobi Sho-Silva, Scott Simons.

Source:  https://www.carlisleunited.co.uk/news/2023/may/club-retained-and-released-list/

Defender Joel Senior is one of nine players to be released by Carlisle after their promotion to League One. The right-back played all 120 minutes of the Cumbrians' League Two play-off final triumph against Stockport. Senior, 23, made 16 appearances for the club this season, having signed from Altrincham in January 2022.