Not sure now is the time for positivity

But Rose is absolute class. The best player we have had since returning to the league.

So class he cant last 90 minutes. His passing was shocking today. And he’s nowhere near the best player we’ve had since being back in the league. He looks “good” in a very inconsistent poor side

Quoted from 3610

Not sure now is the time for positivity

But Rose is absolute class. The best player we have had since returning to the league.

Surely though taketh thy pisss

Omar Bogle? Siriki Dembele? Dean Henderson? What's wrong with your memory?

Quoted from Chrisblor

Omar Bogle? Siriki Dembele? Dean Henderson? What's wrong with your memory?

No chance. Going from League One down to League Two easily trumps going from League Two to the Champions League.

Quoted from Chrisblor

Omar Bogle? Siriki Dembele? Dean Henderson? What's wrong with your memory?

alcohol.

Rose is a tidy enough player and could be a useful cog in midfield, but he is in no way an exceptional stand out player at our level

I mean I’m glad Salford clarified that he’s been on the sauce...Rose is just another player in a long line of players that in ten years we won’t even remember...

Quoted from 3610

Not sure now is the time for positivity

But Rose is absolute class. The best player we have had since returning to the league.

Alongside a couple of these, it’s not difficult to look competent. I’m not convinced he’s any better than Hess.

Quoted from 3610

Not sure now is the time for positivity

But Rose is absolute class. The best player we have had since returning to the league.

He kept losing the ball today which gave the other side chances in goal, but I do think he’s still half decent.

He's a proven performer and a player who is more than comfortable in League 2. Don't think we've seen the best of him, or us as a team yet.

Dembele. Bogle. You can make strong arguments for. Henderson is a keeper. Not having that.

But even though I’ve had a ton of cider. I still think rose is absolute class. Those that said he gave the ball away a lot today I say bull excrement. His positioning and thought of pass is a level above.  

Watch him off the ball next match. Wonderful footballer.

Quoted from 3610

Dembele. Bogle. You can make strong arguments for. Henderson is a keeper. Not having that.

But even though I’ve had a ton of cider. I still think rose is absolute class. Those that said he gave the ball away a lot today I say bull excrement. His positioning and thought of pass is a level above.  

Watch him off the ball next match. Wonderful footballer.

Forget trying to be positive about town player bud... this lot just think we're full of shite players and a crud manager who's not going to do any good...I truly despair!!

What was said about Mohsni by Holloway? Sure I heard it on the commentary driving back from fishing that Ollie said he made a mistake signing him or did I hear wrong?

Quoted from 3610

Dembele. Bogle. You can make strong arguments for. Henderson is a keeper. Not having that.

But even though I’ve had a ton of cider. I still think rose is absolute class. Those that said he gave the ball away a lot today I say bull excrement. His positioning and thought of pass is a level above.  

Watch him off the ball next match. Wonderful footballer.

I was always class off the ball but excrement with it.

Quoted from monkeyboy

What was said about Mohsni by Holloway? Sure I heard it on the commentary driving back from fishing that Ollie said he made a mistake signing him or did I hear wrong?

He said the other day in hindsight he wish he never signed him as his fitness levels seem way below what they should be.

😂😂😂😂

You think he is excrement yeah?

Look at his record you girl private.

Had a mare today though. But he is class.

No he isnt he’s flipping garbage.

Quoted from Hagrid

No he isnt he’s flipping garbage.

Haha

Rose is decent, Ollie should always start with him and Clifton in the middle.

He’s struggled today, him and Taylor don’t look a good pairing. May be useful with Clifton next to him.

He’s not in the top 10 players we’ve had since we’ve been back in the league. He’s not even close to being our best player at the minute. Not that I think he’s bad.

If rose is playing then he needs the energy of Clifton with him. Rose is decent, nowt special, had a nightmare today tho so could hardly complain at being dropped

I can't believe this thread had reached 3 pages without someone saying Salfordmariner is looking at it through Rose-tinted spectacles.  :P

Quoted from KingstonMariner

I can't believe this thread had reached 3 pages without someone saying Salfordmariner is looking at it through Rose-tinted spectacles.  :P

Haha.

To be fair I was hammered when I wrote that

And watched him at Pompey a few times when they went up. Talk to any Pompey fan. And they will probably be the only ones who agree with me on this!

Quoted from 3610

Haha.

To be fair I was hammered when I wrote that

And watched him at Pompey a few times when they went up. Talk to any Pompey fan. And they will probably be the only ones who agree with me on this!

Strange. I always talk sense when I’ve had a few. 😉

Quoted from Hagrid

No he isnt he’s flipping garbage.

The person who thinks Matt Green is worth a starting spot thinks that Rose is garbage.

A great way to out yourself as knowing intercourse all about football.

Been brought down to our level.

He’s certainly a tidy player but not really a game changer, sadly (as with many others) I thought it was his worst performance today
He is also one of only a few experienced players we have, and I’d like to see him show more leadership and vocal encouragement to some of the younger players

Quoted from pontoonlew

The person who thinks Matt Green is worth a starting spot thinks that Rose is garbage.

A great way to out yourself as knowing intercourse all about football.

Silly little boy. Find anywhere where i’ve said he’s worth a starting spot. Said he’s best of a bad bunch.     What on earth has Rose done thus far to show anything. I’ll tell you. Nothing. He and the rest, not good enough

Rose has good moments where he shows his experience and ability to mix short and longer passing. Today, however, he was caught in possession a few times and failed to knit the midfield together with periods of possession.
He should be directing the play and holding his position in front of the CB's, bringing them out to squeeze space in midfield. As soon as the game is stretched, Rose is in danger of running out of gas causing Taylor and Clifton to cover the space.

We were out gunned in midfield by a side who, like Hull, moved well off the ball and passed to feet. Rose and Taylor are useless in the air and were out passed on the deck. Taking Williams off and leaving Gibson and Scannel on made the task even harder for Rose who was shattered in the second half. But for Clifton's energy, it could have been 6/7 nil. Rose has to stay central and build an understanding with Waterfall, Pollock and Macca. Too few players on the same wavelength.

Quoted from Hagrid

Silly little boy. Find anywhere where i’ve said he’s worth a starting spot. Said he’s best of a bad bunch.     What on earth has Rose done thus far to show anything. I’ll tell you. Nothing. He and the rest, not good enough

Depends if you've watched him in other games before today, or just today where he was absolutely dreadful.

Quoted from Tommy

Depends if you've watched him in other games before today, or just today where he was absolutely dreadful.

Ive watched every match this season. But we wont agree so lets leave it :)

Rose seems a decent enough player for this level, I wouldn't say he is a top league 2 midfielder and he certainly isn't the worst midfielder in league 2 this season, but out of Hessenthaler and Rose I do prefer Hessenthaler from what I have seen so far

I’m fairness to Rose he has given the ball away a fair bit but mainly because he’s had to dwell on it too long as the movements around him is so p1ss poor.

Give him a decent mid field partner and some experience ahead of him and he’ll do a decent job for us.

He's another player we've signed four years too late.

Quoted from KingstonMariner

Strange. I always talk sense when I’ve had a few. 😉

Did you stop drinking 5 years ago ?  :-/

I really like Rose but, like everyone else, he was garbage on Saturday.

Because of the lack of quality and confidence in the side, his options are very limited when he has the ball.  That's the same for everyone in the side.  With the exception of Edwards, no-one seemed to want the ball and there was an awful lot of hiding behind players or making runs that didn't actually present an option but rather avoided having to come short and show.

When not in possession it's quite clear he's played at a higher level and reads the game very well.  For him to be most effective though he needs either a box-to-box man in there with him or a bit of a playmaker.  Taylor seems to want to do the same job as Rose, but isn't at that level yet.   Now that's probably not  Taylor's fault, you are the type of player you are.  It's down to Holloway to find the right balance in the middle.

Quoted from golfer

Did you stop drinking 5 years ago ?  :-/

Cheeky barsteward! I’ll have you know I’m a bona fide lush.

Thought I would bump this thread. Some hilarious opinions of tonight's MOM.

Quoted from ginnywings

Thought I would bump this thread. Some hilarious opinions of tonight's MOM.

In your opinion MOM. Played well though, best game for us for sure

Quoted from Hagrid

In your opinion MOM. Played well though, best game for us for sure

Did it count as him finally doing something for you?

Quoted from Rodley Mariner

Did it count as him finally doing something for you?

Yeah. That allright? flipping hell im allowed an opinion pal

Quoted from Hagrid

Yeah. That allright? flipping hell im allowed an opinion pal

Of course you are. And if it's a ludicrously over-the-top one we're allowed to gently tease you over it when it gets shown up.

Different player alongside Hewitt. Hewitt deserves a lot of praise, it’s his first game since early September after all.

Quoted from Rodley Mariner

Of course you are. And if it's a ludicrously over-the-top one we're allowed to gently tease you over it when it gets shown up.

Still stick by it. I dont feel he’d done much for us but im happy to be proved wrong. UTM

Quoted from Hagrid

Still stick by it. I dont feel he’d done much for us but im happy to be proved wrong. UTM

But you said he was 'fooking garbage' earlier in the thread.

Quoted from MuddyWaters

Different player alongside Hewitt. Hewitt deserves a lot of praise, it’s his first game since early September after all.

Agree, and at least our throw ins had purpose which was a bonus too  :)

Quoted from ginnywings

But you said he was 'fooking garbage' earlier in the thread.

We’ve won. And you seem more interested in scoring cheap points. My opinion after a 5-0 loss. Overreaction? Yes. Happy?

Quoted from Hagrid

We’ve won. And you seem more interested in scoring cheap points. My opinion after a 5-0 loss. Overreaction? Yes. Happy?

Fair enough.  :)

Quoted from Hagrid

We’ve won. And you seem more interested in scoring cheap points. My opinion after a 5-0 loss. Overreaction? Yes. Happy?

Take it on the chin Hagrid, I was one of those who thought Gavin Gunning was ok so we all see players differently. You should have been around when Mike Hickman was playing for a player who divided opinion. He took some stick from the old Barrett Stand.

Quoted from Lincoln Mariner 56

Take it on the chin Hagrid, I was one of those who thought Gavin Gunning was ok so we all see players differently. You should have been around when Mike Hickman was playing for a player who divided opinion. He took some stick from the old Barrett Stand.

Bloody boring mate. We’re all entitled to an opinion. Many of us have them, but seems to be whatever i flipping say theres someone who wants to have a dig back. Sick of this flipping site and the way life is. Sick to death of it

Nobody is having a go at you Hagrid it is just a bit of teasing after a good result. I'm sure the last thing anybody wanted, including myself was to upset you but if you say someone is garbage and has done nothing and he plays really well 3 days later then you might get a little tease. Don't take it personally.

Quoted from Hagrid

Bloody boring mate. We’re all entitled to an opinion. Many of us have them, but seems to be whatever i flipping say theres someone who wants to have a dig back. Sick of this flipping site and the way life is. Sick to death of it

I wasn't singling out anyone when I bumped the thread. It was you that responded, but if you feel I'm having a pop at you, apologies, it wasn't intended.

It's a great and unexpected win tonight. Let's focus on that.

One of the reasons Rose was everywhere for the final 85 minutes was he knew he could have done better in the moments before they scored. At first, it seemed he was carrying on from his poor game on Saturday but he showed leadership, experience  and character to battle back and for once we didn't miss Hess ironically.

I have to eat humble pie re Scannell. He also had a slow start but then started to win his battles too and linked well with full backs, Edwards and Wright to put Crawley's defence under pressure. Well done to both.

MOM - Waterfall