Disley and clay

At
Home for me, these 2 must start, dis showed how much he brings to us in those 20 minutes he was on, and clay has been impressive from the start yet finds himself out the team? Hope to see both start on tuesday. thoughts?

agreed , proper fighter disley, had to keep quiet last saturday after that ridiculous booking.

You have hit the Nail on the head there ...........  Hurst should have changed it today after 10 min though .

Why are we playing two holding midfielders and why are we so defensive it's so frustrating there's a game to be won and we are too defensive from the start.

Paddy Mclaughlin?

I'd send pell back, he has a proper lack of heart, he can play but he's a big fanny!

Quoted from jimgtfc

Paddy Mclaughlin?

Not given the same chances the others are.

Quoted from chaos33

Not given the same chances the others are.

Never given a run in the middle of the park. Seems the easiest to drop for some reason.

Quoted from jimgtfc

Paddy Mclaughlin?

you mean play paddy McLaughlin in his best position, and give him a proper run in it too ?

nah paul has his own and sometimes bizarre ideas about that.

Please send Parslow and Pell back. We have 4 centre mids at the club who are better than them.

I don't think Disley gets the credit he deserves sometimes, for me after Mckeown he's been player of the year these last couple of seasons, he does have off days like most players and this usually comes after he's been overplayed.

Quoted from 2578

I don't think Disley gets the credit he deserves sometimes, for me after Mckeown he's been player of the year these last couple of seasons, he does have off days like most players and this usually comes after he's been overplayed.

Agreed, but for me, he plays better in a 3, but as 2 I'd have Clay and Brown in there from the start.

Back to the old birdie , not knowing his best eleven , how to play them or whdn to sub them . Gone back 4 years .

Quoted from jimgtfc

Paddy Mclaughlin?

Not good enough, and Hurst must agree as he has never really been first choice.

If PH doesn't know his best XI I'll do it for him

Macca
Aswad
Pearson
Toto
Magnay
Neilson
Clay
Brown
Mackreth
JP
Shop

Simples

Were allowed 5 subs

This thread title sounds like a 70s pop group.

If we had a manager who had faith with our squad,

He would play a more attacking formation at home,

Our home results would then read ,

Won 9  Drawn 2  Lost 0

Instead of

Won 5   Drawn 3 Lost 3

I have said it before Hurst is far too cautious ,

He is not a bad manager but he is not the manager to take us up.

[quote=672]If we had a manager who had faith with our squad,

He would play a more attacking formation at home,

Our home results would then read ,

Won 9  Drawn 2  Lost 0

Instead of

Won 5   Drawn 3 Lost 3

I have said it before Hurst is far too cautious ,

He is not a bad manager but he is not the manager to take us up.[/quote]



I think you are spot on here and I think this level of football is his ceiling. He can spot good players but doesn't seem to know how best to utilise them.

Quoted from fishyrich

If PH doesn't know his best XI I'll do it for him

Macca
Aswad
Pearson
Toto
Magnay
Neilson
Clay
Brown
Mackreth
JP
Shop

Simples

Mackreth???

Quoted from gtfc98

Mackreth???

I know he's Colbeck in disguise but we're not exactly spoilt for choice on the right. We've got a squad full of centre mids

JP on the right and Hannah or Hamish (or Southwell!!) up top with shop.

We need to be playing 4-4-2 is what I'm getting at

UTM

Or Hey Arnold on the right but he does leave Magnay a bit exposed

Thoughts?

Quoted from arryarryarry

Not good enough, and Hurst must agree as he has never really been first choice.

To be fair to Paddy he has hardly had a chance in his favoured central midfield position. I'd agree with others that he isn't ideal in a midfield 2 and has shown that but when he's in a midfield 3 (as he was at York) and earlier in the season when we knocked 7 past Alfreton etc in that spell he showed he's a real good player. I don't see how he isn't even in the squad now especially as we are back to playing 3 in midfield. Yet again we have bought 2 loanees in that haven't really improved the squad.

Will feel really sorry for Paddy if Pell's loan is extended. Paddy is a better player IMO and should be given a chance on Tuesday.

Not gonna happen mate. Paddy is the only one of the central midfielders who hasn't had a fair chance in a season and a half in centre midfield. He's had the odd game there, or has been used at left mid or left back. Sure he's had the odd quiet game, but generally hasn't let anyone down in whatever position he's been asked to play. Often he's looked very dangerous and has scored some great, important goals. 10 minutes here and there from the bench every few weeks is no good. He's a very good player with great attacking qualities. I can only think that this is why Hurst doesn't fancy him - he doesn't have the defensive credentials that perhaps the others do. He does, however, have the ability to run at players and has great energy and vision, with plenty of goals in him. I don't think any of the other centre midfielders, loaned or under contract, have those strengths to the degree that he has.

Quoted from chaos33

Not gonna happen mate. Paddy is the only one of the central midfielders who hasn't had a fair chance in a season and a half in centre midfield. He's had the odd game there, or has been used at left mid or left back. Sure he's had the odd quiet game, but generally hasn't let anyone down in whatever position he's been asked to play. Often he's looked very dangerous and has scored some great, important goals. 10 minutes here and there from the bench every few weeks is no good. He's a very good player with great attacking qualities. I can only think that this is why Hurst doesn't fancy him - he doesn't have the defensive credentials that perhaps the others do. He does, however, have the ability to run at players and has great energy and vision, with plenty of goals in him. I don't think any of the other centre midfielders, loaned or under contract, have those strengths to the degree that he has.

Agree with this. Such a shame as it just seems such a waste of a good player. As you say he hasn't been given a fair chance.

Fair comments Phil. Think Paddy has had a raw deal, and done a very decent job for the side playing out of position. I'd be a tad unhappy if I were him.

There are a few players who have been performing below par but never get questioned. I think Mckeown has been below par, defensively Toto has been disappointing, Pearson inconsistent, midfield people quick to jump on Disley but he's had just a good as season as others in there. Clay came into the side almost by accident, people slaughtered him but he performed better than he was supposed to. Brown had a good opening month but since then very average. Macheth has proved disappointing, Nielson has ability but again inconsistent, that's why he's at Conference level. Lennell gets hammered but it's his best season yet, Pitman not really had a run of games, Hannah we have turned into a player not 30% of what he was when he signed, partly through how we play and partly through confidence. Arnold looks a class above at times but again inconsistent.

On the whole this is the worst standard of Conference since we've been in. We should be capable of winning it but it'll be play off disappointment again in my honest opinion. There'll be loan signings in January, and I think has to be a more positive approach at home, ie 2 strikers, and people need to perform better consistently.

Not sure people realise financial implications of another season at this level, this has to be done this season - getting out this league. But the manager should stop moaning about fans, and start appreciating the ones who have stuck by them. The team need support, but the support need the team. It's not a given..or shouldn't be..start taking the bull by the horns and play in a way that people want to pay and watch. Results all important of course but not the solitary thing to get bums on seats.

There's a negative vibe around the club, has been for years, emanating from the top in my humble opinoon, but it is what it is..can talk about new ground, and negative support, and luck, whatever..be all and end all is get back into the league before its too late.

Quoted from chaos33

Not gonna happen mate. Paddy is the only one of the central midfielders who hasn't had a fair chance in a season and a half in centre midfield. He's had the odd game there, or has been used at left mid or left back. Sure he's had the odd quiet game, but generally hasn't let anyone down in whatever position he's been asked to play. Often he's looked very dangerous and has scored some great, important goals. 10 minutes here and there from the bench every few weeks is no good. He's a very good player with great attacking qualities. I can only think that this is why Hurst doesn't fancy him - he doesn't have the defensive credentials that perhaps the others do. He does, however, have the ability to run at players and has great energy and vision, with plenty of goals in him. I don't think any of the other centre midfielders, loaned or under contract, have those strengths to the degree that he has.

Just another player with shattered confidence......plus add Hannah to the list too

Only hurst doing his usual

Quoted from marinerjase

Fair comments Phil. Think Paddy has had a raw deal, and done a very decent job for the side playing out of position. I'd be a tad unhappy if I were him.

There are a few players who have been performing below par but never get questioned. I think Mckeown has been below par, defensively Toto has been disappointing, Pearson inconsistent, midfield people quick to jump on Disley but he's had just a good as season as others in there. Clay came into the side almost by accident, people slaughtered him but he performed better than he was supposed to. Brown had a good opening month but since then very average. Macheth has proved disappointing, Nielson has ability but again inconsistent, that's why he's at Conference level. Lennell gets hammered but it's his best season yet, Pitman not really had a run of games, Hannah we have turned into a player not 30% of what he was when he signed, partly through how we play and partly through confidence. Arnold looks a class above at times but again inconsistent.

On the whole this is the worst standard of Conference since we've been in. We should be capable of winning it but it'll be play off disappointment again in my honest opinion. There'll be loan signings in January, and I think has to be a more positive approach at home, ie 2 strikers, and people need to perform better consistently.

Not sure people realise financial implications of another season at this level, this has to be done this season - getting out this league. But the manager should stop moaning about fans, and start appreciating the ones who have stuck by them. The team need support, but the support need the team. It's not a given..or shouldn't be..start taking the bull by the horns and play in a way that people want to pay and watch. Results all important of course but not the solitary thing to get bums on seats.

There's a negative vibe around the club, has been for years, emanating from the top in my humble opinoon, but it is what it is..can talk about new ground, and negative support, and luck, whatever..be all and end all is get back into the league before its too late.

Good post Jase.

It may well be the worst Standard of football since we have been at this level but looking at results across the league suggests it is the most competitive it has been.

At present only ONE team has won the last two consecutive games. That is astounding and shows that consistency just doesn't happen in this league. So far only Barnet had found it, whoever has it in the 2nd half of the season will go up.

Away from home we have been decent enough, I enjoy away games more than home ones at present. At BP we need to go for it more, take the game to the opposition. We can still play 4-5-1 or 4-3-3 but only if the central midfield gets beyond strikers and the holding midfielder means the full backs have licence to bomb forward.
I'd love us to challenge the opposition. Say to them ' we reckon we are better than you and are going to prove it". Ask em 'what you got'

I can't comment on PH comments as I haven't heard them. Some are "outraged" some say he doesn't say much at all. For me I never attach much to any managers post match comments, it's what he says in the dressing room that makes a difference but in reality it is what happens in the 90+ mins that has bearing on feelings and comments. Win and everybody's happy and job done

Good post BC.

Quoted from jimgtfc

Paddy Mclaughlin?

The central midfielder that hasn't put a tackle in in his life.

A few months ago Disley was a regular scapegoat when results didn't go our way. Now most seem to want him in the team. Funny old game.

Quoted from Tommy

A few months ago Disley was a regular scapegoat when results didn't go our way. Now most seem to want him in the team. Funny old game.

for me mate, ive always wanted dis in the team, I think he is our most attacking midfielder and most likely to pop up in the box and get a goal, hopefully others are starting to realize this, just a shame he probably cant manage 3 games a week now etc etc

I think Disley is ponderous in possession, slow and unable to dominate the opposition midfield. The natural attacking threat of players such as Nielsen, Mackreth, Arnold even McLaughlin is wasted on this manager.

If he wants supporters off his back give em something to flipping enjoy watching, be bold, especially at home.

#hurstball , it's like a sh1t version of sladeball.

Playoff misery awaits if we are lucky.

Quoted from fishyrich

If PH doesn't know his best XI I'll do it for him

Macca
Aswad
Pearson
Toto
Magnay
Neilson
Clay
Brown
Mackreth
JP
Shop

Simples

I disagree. I think our best side at home is:

McKeown

Magnay
Toto
Pearson
Aza

Arnold
Disley/Clay (Depending on the opposition)
Brown
Neilson

Pittman
Lenny

And away:

McKeown

Magnay
Toto
Pearson
Aza

Parslow
Disley/Clay (Depending on the opposition)
Brown

MacKreth
Lenny
Arnold